Results 1 to 2 of 2
Thread: What is the problem (quicksort)?
 10282012, 06:44 PM #1Member
 Join Date
 Oct 2012
 Posts
 6
 Rep Power
 0
What is the problem (quicksort)?
Hi all. I am currently working on quicksort and have written the following code and gives "almost" good results. I am not too fond of the data structure I have chosen but it is too late for me to change. Lesson learned. Can anyone help me debug this thing. I have been at it for a while. Anyway here is the code:
Java Code:static Random myGen = new Random(); public static void quickSort(DLinkedList unsortedList, int start, int finish){ int randpiv; int offset = 0; if(finish == 1){ randpiv = 0; }else{ randpiv = myGen.nextInt(finish+1); } if(finish  start <= 1){ return; } for(int i = start; i < randpiv; i++){ if(unsortedList.distofElem(i) >= unsortedList.distofElem(randpiv)){ offset++; DLNode moveMe = unsortedList.removeDist(unsortedList.distofElem(i)); unsortedList.insertAfter(moveMe, randpiv); } } for(int i = randpiv + offset + 1; i <= finish; i++){ if(unsortedList.distofElem(i) < unsortedList.distofElem(randpiv)){ DLNode moveMe = unsortedList.removeDist(unsortedList.distofElem(i)); unsortedList.insertBefore(moveMe, randpiv); } } quickSort(unsortedList, start, randpiv  1); quickSort(unsortedList, randpiv + 1, finish); } //here are insert after and insert before// //insert before an index// public void insertBefore(DLNode putMe, int index){ listLength++; int intTemp = 0; for(temp = myRoot; intTemp < index; temp = temp.next){ intTemp++; } System.out.println("Inserting: " + putMe.getDistance() + " BEFORE: " + temp.getDistance()); if(temp == myRoot){ myRoot.prev = putMe; putMe.next = myRoot; putMe.prev = null; myRoot = myRoot.prev; }else{ temp.prev.next = putMe; putMe.prev = temp.prev; temp.prev = putMe; putMe.next = temp; } } //insert after an index// public void insertAfter(DLNode putMe, int index){ listLength++; int intTemp = 0; for(temp = myRoot; intTemp < index; temp = temp.next){ intTemp++; } System.out.println("Inserting: " + putMe.getDistance() + " AFTER: " + temp.getDistance()); if(temp == myTail){ myTail.next = putMe; putMe.prev = myTail; putMe.next = null; myTail = myTail.next; }else{ temp.next.prev = putMe; putMe.next = temp.next; temp.next = putMe; putMe.prev = temp; } }
29403 97291 7211 487075 10000000 9902 89600 1620 22500 180000 152 10 14700 1026046 6646 19769 17708 10201 16250 533026 1424561 880025 12930 91210 25004 580800 926718
Here is the output i get:
10
152
1620
6646
7211
9902
10201
12930
14700
16250
17708
19769
22500
25004
29403
89600
97291
180000
487075
880025
533026
1424561
91210
10000000
1026046
580800
926718
which is close, but not quite.
Thanks for reading.
 10302012, 06:30 PM #2
Re: What is the problem (quicksort)?
I don't have time to step through your code line by line at the moment, but looking at the data, my guess is that one or several of your calls are either terminating early, or you have a bug in your partition code (an off by 1 index sometimes will do this).
I suggest you make the smallest list you can (like 5 or 10 elements) in which the problem still occurs, and then step through the algorithm using the debugger while simultaneously doing it on a sheet of graph paper. At each step, do it on graph paper (with the master list and all the partitioned sub lists) so you will know the expected state of the list. Then see how the actual code is different.
I had similar problems years ago, and it was something to do with my partitioning  don't remember exactly what, but it was either goofy median placement, or I had or was missing a >= instead of just a >  something like that. Essentially, it was moving my bounds index off by 1 in only one direction.
Good luck!
Similar Threads

Quicksort median
By louboulos in forum New To JavaReplies: 6Last Post: 05162012, 10:36 PM 
my Quicksort attempt has failed
By Jeremy8 in forum New To JavaReplies: 4Last Post: 11162009, 03:56 AM 
problem with quicksort
By jvasilj1 in forum New To JavaReplies: 2Last Post: 03052009, 01:09 AM 
quicksort program
By jvasilj1 in forum New To JavaReplies: 5Last Post: 03032009, 04:47 AM 
Quicksort
By little_polarbear in forum New To JavaReplies: 12Last Post: 07122008, 09:20 PM
Bookmarks